Farquhar's Executor v. Georgia
American lawyers will recognize - if not, also be familiar with - the Supreme Court decision known as Chisholm v. Georgia . It was perhaps the first major decision of John Jay's Supreme Court. It is noteworthy because it is the reason why we have the Eleventh Amendment in the Constitution. The case itself was about - what else - money: unpaid war debts. Georgia didn't want to pay what it owed for war supplies to a South Carolina merchant, Robert Farquhar. Unfortunately, Farquhar died in a sailing accident during the process of petition and litigation; the executor of his estate, Alexander Chisholm ("Farquhar's Executor"), subsequently took over the legal proceedings on behalf of the Farquhar estate and attempted to sue the State of Georgia. In his view, the Constitution and the Judiciary Act gave him tools to seek relief in the Federal Courts. Many people know about the famous case, Chisholm v. Georgia , which decided 4-1 in Chisholm's favor. ...


